PuTTY bug unclean-close-crash

This is a mirror. Follow this link to find the primary PuTTY web site.

summary: Reports of crashes on unclean close (related to port forwarding?)
class: bug: This is clearly an actual problem we want fixed.
priority: historic: This is an old bug report that we think is either fixed without noticing, or confined to old systems, or too vague.
present-in: 0.55 0.56 2004-11-29 2005-01-16 2005-01-24 2009-02-10

We are getting persistent reports of PuTTY crashing when a session is closed uncleanly, for instance by a network error such as "software caused connection abort". This limits the usefulness of the ability to restart dead sessions that was introduced in recent releases.

(Some people are apparently in the habit of hibernating their machines with active PuTTY connections. When the machines come back up, the network connections are likely to be invalid, so PuTTY throws a network error and gives the same problem.)

Many (all?) of the reports indicate that port-forwarding is in use. We've not yet been able to reproduce it.

See also unclean-close-hang, which seems more or less specific to Windows Vista and Windows 7, and definitely doesn't require port forwarding to be active.

Reports:

OF9474F5EC.6EF0B984-ON80256E55.00617997-80256E55.0061B13F@plasmon.co.uk
0.53b; pfd; NULL ptr ref?
4073CD52.8090404@attunity.co.il
0.53+(0.53b, 0.54?); pfd; SCCA
debug info -- apparent use of bogus ssh
6.1.2.0.2.20040922120006.01a98a18@imap.hut.fi
0.55; pfd; network error; sending on port causes crash
20041117185616.1516.qmail@web41502.mail.yahoo.com
0.56; pfd; SCCA; PuTTY using excessive CPU
E1CYwFK-0003zT-00@ixion.tartarus.org
0.56, r4918(2004-11-29); pfd; SCCA
also assertion ssh.c:3365 ssh->state == SSH_STATE_CLOSED
200501090053.j090roW0028426@q7.q7.com
0.56, 2005-01-16; pfd; SCCA; tunnels still open; Dr Watson
41F4C327.20905@hybrid.fi
0.56 and 2005-01-24; pfd; SCCA; stack backtrace (apparent use of bogus ssh)
also sees assertion ssh.c:3365 ssh->state == SSH_STATE_CLOSED with 0.56
20050128171423.GB719@firebyte.bytnar.net
0.55/0.56; pfd; SCCA
also SOCKS connections not killed (fixed in 2005-02-18)
200411010710.iA17AJAW014641@smtp.hispeed.ch
0.56; XPSP1; SSH server disconnect ("connection timed out" is fine!)
141902151.20090211120208@kilgus.net
2009-02-10; evidence of use of freed memory (this one fixed in r9069)

Possibly related code activity:

access of freed ssh->channels fixed r4946, s/s 2004-12-03
leaving channels/listening sockets lying around fixed r5325, s/s 2005-02-18
not properly closing port-forwardings in CHAN_SOCKDATA_DORMANT state, fixed r9069, s/s 2011-01-04

SGT, 2024-11-17: classifying this bug as historic. It was last seen in 2009 and there's been a lot of rewriting since. If anyone asks to revive it then I hope they can provide a more specific reproducer.

If you want to comment on this web site, see the Feedback page.

Audit trail for this bug.

(last revision of this bug record was at 2024-11-17 15:29:37 +0000)